Multimedia Lab: Newton's 'Chymistry' of Metal Solubilities

Newton's chymistry was in many cases fully operational and explicable in modern chemical terminology. In order to drive this point home, we have prepared a lab unit, "Newton's 'Chymistry' of Metal Solubilities," that can be employed in schools as an integral part of their science education curricula. The lab unit is divided into three levels of difficulty, although the individual levels all build on the same simple reactions taken from "Query 31" of Newton's Opticks.

The first level, intended for Middle School science courses, involves basic observation of color changes as metals replace one another in solutions. In 2004-5, the exercises depicted here were successfully tested in the 8th- Grade science course taught by Nancy Martin at Jackson Creek Middle School in Bloomington, Indiana. The color changes appearing during the reactions can also be observed in two time-lapse sequences filmed in the laboratory of Cathrine Reck at Indiana University. The first sequence illustrates the reduction of silver from a silver nitrate solution while copper is dissolved in the solution. The second time-lapse sequence depicts the reduction of the previously dissolved copper while iron is dissolved. We recommend that interested viewers who do not have access to a laboratory or properly equipped classroom download the videos below so that they can see what Newton himself observed.

The second level of difficulty ("Extension 1"), intended for beginning High School students, adds a quantitative dimension by introducing the concept of molarity. Carrying out these calculations will give an excellent laboratory introduction to important concepts that the student will encounter on a regular basis in High School Chemistry.

The third level of difficulty ("Extension 2") introduces the concept of Redox, a normal component of advanced High School and beginning College Chemistry courses. The two time-lapse sequences that we provide are in fact examples of Redox reactions.


A hand holding a silver coin with the bottom third gold.
"Transmutation" of Silver into Gold

A medallion composed of a silver-gold alloy is dipped into nitric acid. Some of the silver dissolves, leaving gold. It looks as though the silver has been "transmuted" into gold.

Quicktime


 
Small saw blade in blue liquid inside of a flask.
"Transmutation" of Iron into Copper

The "transmutation" is actually copper-plating of a steel sawblade in a solution of copper sulfate and water.

Quicktime


 
Large flask of white liquid with ribbons of red.
Silica Garden Illustrating Mineral "Vegetation"

In Newton's day, a silica garden was usually made by placing ferric chloride lumps in a solution of potassium silicate, as in the following demonstration.

Quicktime


 
In a flask, a lump of silver metal with spikes growing out of it.
"Tree of Diana"

A crystalline growth emerges from a globular amalgam of silver and mercury in a solution of silver and mercury dissolved in nitric acid.

Quicktime


 
Flask viewed from above containing a green liquid.
Copper Dissolving in a Solution of Silver Nitrate

Copper dissolving in a solution of silver nitrate while the silver comes out of solution in metallic form.

Quicktime


 
Flask viewed from above containing iron shot.
Iron Shot Dissolving in the Solution of Copper Nitrate

Iron shot dissolving in the solution of copper nitrate formed during the previous reaction.

Quicktime


 
Adobe Acrobat link

Adobe Reader can be downloaded for free from http://www.adobe.com/products/acrobat/readermain.html

Apple Quicktime link

QuickTime player can be downloaded for free in Mac and Windows versions from http://www.apple.com/quicktime/download/

Collection by: William R. Newman, History of Science Professor, Indiana University | Copyright 2005- , William R. Newman | Updated: 9/19/11 9:21 AM
In collaboration with the IU Digital Library Program | Libraries Privacy Policy | In association with The Newton Project - University of Sussex | URL: http://webapp1.dlib.indiana.edu/newton/reference/chemLab.do

This material is based upon work supported by the National Science Foundation under Grant Nos. 0324310 and 0620868 and by the National Endowment for the Humanities under Grant No. RZ-50798. Any opinions, findings, and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Science Foundation or the National Endowment for the Humanities.